- Capitalism and Alternatives -

Re: one cannot seize power, one must end it...

Posted by: don T. on June 10, 1997 at 10:09:02:

In Reply to: one cannot seize power, one must end it... posted by Red Deathy on June 07, 1997 at 21:14:22:

A bit of clarification on Lenin and the vanguard and Trotsky...

Lenin did not lead a coup d'etat nor does a vanguard party mean just that. Russia was a workers' state in 1917, no it was not truly socialist but the working class was indeed in the saddle. Soviets, workers' councils were set up, the ruling class was kicked out and workers' effectively took over the means of production (factories, etc.) Without a vanguard party like the Bolsheviks, the revolution would have been defeated. In fact, because of the lack of a revolutionary socialist organisation, revolutions were able to be defeated in Italy and Germany 1918. Capitalism is organised and geared to beating back any fundamental changed, so workers must be organised to overthrow the system that oppresses them.

Trotsky devised the theory of Permanent Revolution which is simply that a that an island of socialism cannot exist in a sea of capitalism, the socialist revolution must occur in all nations of the world. Lenin also held this belief of internationalism up until his death in '24. In fact, his last struggle was against Stalin and his eventual betrayal of the Oct. '17 revolution.


Follow Ups:

The Debating Room Post a Followup