Re: Scripture (was: Unlikely Existence of God)


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Skeptics Society Message Board ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Sonkist on December 31, 1996 at 17:28:09:

In Reply to: Scripture (was: Unlikely Existence of God) posted by Jason on December 30, 1996 at 18:16:25:


: (This post is a reply to Lynn's comments)

: In your previous post you said that I may get proof of a
: spiritual realm but it would be from the Anti-Christ who would
: perform signs and wonders. When this begins, you claimed that
: people with anti-Christian sentiments would start the
: persecution of Christians. You also wanted to discuss biblical
: scripture.

: To start, I would like to say that I am not your enemy. I'm not
: anti-Christian but more accurately, I'm non-Christian. Just because
: you're not a Bahai doesn't mean you're anti-Bahai does it? Like I
: said before, I can respect the religious beliefs of others but I
: cannot embrace them. Also, even if some guy showed me that he had
: supernatural powers, I'd rather die than persecute people for their
: religious beliefs (and I'm sure that most people who post here
: would agree with me).

: Getting into biblical scripture, I do have a few questions. I'm
: sure that you're familiar with the Mosaic Law in the OT. Here's an
: example:

: "If anyone secretly entices you-- even if it is your
: brother, your father's son or your mother's son, or
: your own son or daughter, or the wife you embrace, or
: your most intimate friend-- saying, "Let us go worship
: other gods," .... you must not yield to or heed any
: such persons. Show them no pity or compassion and do
: not shield them. But you shall surely kill them; your
: own hand shall be first against them to execute them,
: and afterwards the hand of all the people."
: (Deut. 13:6,8-9)

: Now if you were an Israelite living in OT times, would you really
: obey such an order? If I was the Israelite I would have said,
: "God, you may have the might but you don't have the right!" Like
: I said, I'd rather die than persecute people because of their
: religious beliefs. There's more. Mosaic Law commanded the death
: penalty for things like: not keeping the sabbath, being a
: stubborn son, homosexuality, and adultery. In addition, things
: like genocide and murdering infants and children are routinely
: commanded to the Israelites by a supposedly omnibenevolent deity.
: If you subscribe to "Skeptic" perhaps you may have read John
: Hartung's essay on religious xenophobia and genocide in the OT
: (vol.3, no.4).

: You would probably argue that Jesus fulfilled the OT law and
: is therefore negated. However, this still doesn't change
: the fact that these kind of laws are barbaric and reprehensible.
: Even if these laws were negated later on, they are totally
: inconsistent with the idea of an omnibenevolent deity. Now
: compare the Mosaic Law with something like the Universal
: Declaration of Human Rights. Supposedly, one of these systems
: was inspired by an omnibenevolent deity, and another by sinful
: imperfect humans. Which system appears more benevolent to you?

: I should point out that there is a group called the Christian
: Reconstruction movement who think that the OT law should still
: be applied today. They believe that Jesus only fulfilled OT
: laws like circumcision, animal sacrifice, and dietary rules.
: From your writing you appear to be a very decent and tolerant
: person, so I can tell that you don't adhere to CR beliefs.
: - Jason

:




Follow Ups:



Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:

Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Skeptics Society Message Board ] [ FAQ ]